da4a971ca9
Adds common_libs/tests/measure_melee_bitbrain_ab.nim (+ .sh driver, .py analyzer,
committed per-run fixtures) and docs/melee_bitbrain_ab.md.
Experiment: 4-bot Free-For-All (ModularBot + WaveSurfer + PatternMover +
RandomMover), 4 arms x 16 runs x 7 rounds, frozen ModularBot from git archive
HEAD (commit 0f5cfe3, binary 11bba27), shipped tfil movement in every run.
Arms differ only in the gun rack: pattern (shipped), bb_round, bb_ret, bb_learn.
Result: NOT DETECTABLE. Score (server round score = damage + survival bonus)
differs by -63..+33 pts (perm p=0.16-0.71) against an MDE of 151 (~5.1%).
Every arm finishes rank 1. Round wins hint BitBrain's way (112/112 and 111/112
vs 109/112) but p=0.225 (MW 0.080), half the 0.40-win MDE.
Liveness proven: rack boot lines flip (rack active melee = PATTERN / BITBRAIN),
every run faced 3 distinct targets and ~66-69 target changes, and the bb arms
logged one [bb-reset] reason=target_change per switch. The melee premise was
exercised; the fast adaptation bought no measurable score edge at this sample.
405 lines
16 KiB
Nim
405 lines
16 KiB
Nim
## MELEE A/B: is BitBrain actually better than Pattern in melee?
|
|
##
|
|
## The repo's FIRST melee measurement. Runs a 4-bot Free-For-All
|
|
## (ModularBot + WaveSurfer + PatternMover + RandomMover) for each arm, where
|
|
## the ONLY thing that differs between arms is ModularBot's gun-rack environment
|
|
## (`TR_RACK_*` / `TR_BITBRAIN_*`). Every other bot is held fixed.
|
|
##
|
|
## Why melee needs its own measurement: Pattern's advantage comes from
|
|
## accumulating history with ONE enemy. Melee rotates targets, fragmenting
|
|
## per-enemy history, so a gun that resets per target and re-adapts fast
|
|
## (BitBrain, `TR_BITBRAIN_RESET_ON_TARGET=on` by default) could gain exactly
|
|
## where Pattern loses. That is the hypothesis; this runner produces the number.
|
|
##
|
|
## Design (see docs/melee_bitbrain_ab.md):
|
|
## * arms differ ONLY in the ModularBot wrapper script's exported env;
|
|
## * each run gets its own ModularBot bot-dir + stdout/stderr log, so liveness
|
|
## (`[env] rack active melee = ...`) and target-switching evidence
|
|
## (`[config] ... target=#N`, `[bb-reset] reason=target_change`) are captured;
|
|
## * the runner is driven in one process per arm from a shell driver; each
|
|
## process gets its own Tank Royale server (ephemeral port).
|
|
##
|
|
## Usage:
|
|
## nim c -r --nimcache:/tmp/nc_j116 --path:common_libs \
|
|
## common_libs/tests/measure_melee_bitbrain_ab.nim --list-arms
|
|
##
|
|
## MELEE_SERVER_JAR=<jar> \
|
|
## common_libs/tests/measure_melee_bitbrain_ab.nim \
|
|
## --outdir /tmp/melee_ab --build-only
|
|
##
|
|
## common_libs/tests/measure_melee_bitbrain_ab.nim \
|
|
## --outdir /tmp/melee_ab --arm pattern --run-start 1 --run-count 16
|
|
##
|
|
## Arm env (verbatim, from the arms table below) is written into the per-run
|
|
## wrapper script; the runner process' own environment is NOT mutated for the
|
|
## bot, so parallel arm processes cannot leak into each other.
|
|
|
|
import std/[os, osproc, strutils, strformat, json, sequtils]
|
|
|
|
import test_framework/server_manager
|
|
import test_framework/runner_process
|
|
import test_framework/battle_result
|
|
|
|
# ── the field (fixed across arms) ────────────────────────────────────────────
|
|
const
|
|
repoSuffix = "common_libs" / "test_framework" / "adversaries"
|
|
AdversaryNames = ["WaveSurfer", "PatternMover", "RandomMover"]
|
|
## Mixed field: one strong reactive mover (WaveSurfer, linear gun), one
|
|
## deterministic pattern mover (PatternMover), one erratic mover
|
|
## (RandomMover). All three shoot.
|
|
|
|
# ── the arms (ONLY ModularBot's gun rack differs) ────────────────────────────
|
|
type
|
|
Arm = object
|
|
name*: string
|
|
env*: seq[string] ## "KEY=VALUE", exported in the per-run wrapper script
|
|
note*: string
|
|
|
|
const Arms*: array[4, Arm] = [
|
|
Arm(name: "pattern", env: @[],
|
|
note: "shipped default: Pattern-only rack, no env"),
|
|
Arm(name: "bb_round",
|
|
env: @["TR_RACK_PATTERN=off", "TR_RACK_BITBRAIN=melee",
|
|
"TR_BITBRAIN_MEM=perRound", "TR_BITBRAIN_LOG=1"],
|
|
note: "BitBrain-only melee rack, perRound memory"),
|
|
Arm(name: "bb_ret",
|
|
env: @["TR_RACK_PATTERN=off", "TR_RACK_BITBRAIN=melee",
|
|
"TR_BITBRAIN_MEM=retained", "TR_BITBRAIN_LOG=1"],
|
|
note: "BitBrain-only melee rack, retained memory"),
|
|
Arm(name: "bb_learn",
|
|
env: @["TR_RACK_PATTERN=off", "TR_RACK_BITBRAIN=melee",
|
|
"TR_BITBRAIN_MEM=decay", "TR_BITBRAIN_GAINS=1.0,1.25,1.5,2.0",
|
|
"TR_BITBRAIN_LOG=1"],
|
|
note: "BitBrain-only melee rack, decay memory + learned gains (user config)"),
|
|
]
|
|
|
|
const
|
|
ModularBotJson = """{
|
|
"name": "ModularBot",
|
|
"version": "0.1.0",
|
|
"authors": ["Davide Cappellini"],
|
|
"description": "frozen melee A/B build of ModularBot",
|
|
"homepage": "",
|
|
"countryCodes": ["IT"],
|
|
"gameTypes": ["classic", "1v1"],
|
|
"platform": "Nim",
|
|
"programmingLang": "Nim"
|
|
}
|
|
"""
|
|
|
|
# ANSI SGR sequences (the bot's config line color-highlights changed fields).
|
|
const AnsiRe = "\x1b\\[[0-9;]*m"
|
|
|
|
proc stripAnsi(s: string): string =
|
|
result = newStringOfCap(s.len)
|
|
var i = 0
|
|
while i < s.len:
|
|
if s[i] == '\x1b' and i + 1 < s.len and s[i+1] == '[':
|
|
i += 2
|
|
while i < s.len and s[i] notin {'m'}: inc i
|
|
if i < s.len: inc i # skip the terminating 'm'
|
|
else:
|
|
result.add s[i]
|
|
inc i
|
|
|
|
proc repoRoot(): string =
|
|
currentSourcePath().parentDir.parentDir.parentDir
|
|
|
|
proc quote(s: string): string = quoteShell(s)
|
|
|
|
proc params(): seq[string] =
|
|
for i in 1 .. paramCount(): result.add paramStr(i)
|
|
|
|
proc findParam(args: seq[string], name: string, default = ""): string =
|
|
for i in 0 ..< args.len:
|
|
if args[i] == name and i + 1 < args.len: return args[i+1]
|
|
default
|
|
|
|
proc hasFlag(args: seq[string], name: string): bool =
|
|
for a in args:
|
|
if a == name: return true
|
|
false
|
|
|
|
# ── frozen ModularBot build (from `git archive HEAD`, like tools/ab/ab_run.sh) ─
|
|
|
|
proc binarySha(bin: string): string =
|
|
let (outp, rc) = execCmdEx("sha256sum " & quote(bin))
|
|
if rc == 0: outp.strip().split(' ')[0] else: "unknown"
|
|
|
|
proc headCommit(repo: string): string =
|
|
let (outp, rc) = execCmdEx("git -C " & quote(repo) & " rev-parse HEAD")
|
|
if rc == 0: outp.strip() else: "unknown"
|
|
|
|
proc buildFrozen(repo, outdir: string): string =
|
|
## Compile ONE frozen ModularBot from the committed HEAD snapshot and return
|
|
## its path. A dirty tree cannot leak into the measurement.
|
|
let bin = outdir / "frozen" / "ModularBot_bin"
|
|
if fileExists(bin): return bin
|
|
createDir(outdir / "frozen")
|
|
let snapshot = outdir / "frozen" / "head"
|
|
createDir(snapshot)
|
|
let (arcOut, arcRc) = execCmdEx(
|
|
"git -C " & quote(repo) & " archive HEAD | tar -x -C " & quote(snapshot))
|
|
if arcRc != 0:
|
|
raise newException(IOError, "git archive HEAD failed:\n" & arcOut)
|
|
let garage = snapshot / "ModularBot_garage"
|
|
if not dirExists(garage):
|
|
raise newException(IOError, "no ModularBot_garage in HEAD snapshot")
|
|
let nimcache = outdir / "nimcache"
|
|
let cmd = "nim c -d:release --nimcache:" & quote(nimcache) &
|
|
" --out:" & quote(bin) & " src/ModularBot.nim"
|
|
let (outp, rc) = execCmdEx(cmd, workingDir = garage)
|
|
if rc != 0 or not fileExists(bin):
|
|
raise newException(OSError, "frozen ModularBot build failed:\n" & outp)
|
|
result = bin
|
|
|
|
# ── per-run wrapper bot dir ──────────────────────────────────────────────────
|
|
|
|
proc writeWrapper(botDir: string, env: seq[string], bin, stdoutLog, stderrLog: string) =
|
|
createDir(botDir)
|
|
writeFile(botDir / "ModularBot.json", ModularBotJson)
|
|
var sh = "#!/bin/sh\ncd \"$(dirname \"$0\")\"\n"
|
|
for kv in env:
|
|
let p = kv.split('=', 1)
|
|
sh.add("export " & p[0] & "=\"" & p[1] & "\"\n")
|
|
sh.add("exec ./ModularBot_bin > " & quote(stdoutLog) &
|
|
" 2> " & quote(stderrLog) & "\n")
|
|
writeFile(botDir / "ModularBot.sh", sh)
|
|
discard execCmdEx("chmod +x " & quote(botDir / "ModularBot.sh"))
|
|
if fileExists(botDir / "ModularBot_bin"): removeFile(botDir / "ModularBot_bin")
|
|
createSymlink(bin, botDir / "ModularBot_bin")
|
|
|
|
# ── liveness / target-switching extraction from the bot's stdout ─────────────
|
|
|
|
type Live = object
|
|
envRackPattern: string
|
|
envRackBitbrain: string
|
|
envBitbrainMem: string
|
|
envBitbrainGains: string
|
|
envMovement: string
|
|
rackActiveMelee: string
|
|
rackActive1v1: string
|
|
rackMeleeLines: int
|
|
configLines: int
|
|
distinctTargets: int
|
|
targetChanges: int
|
|
bbResetTargetChange: int
|
|
bbLines: int
|
|
resultEndWon: string
|
|
|
|
proc envLine(text, key: string): string =
|
|
## Value of an `[env] KEY = VALUE` (or `[env] KEY=VALUE`) boot-report line,
|
|
## with the `(source: ...)` annotation stripped. Empty when absent.
|
|
let prefix = "[env] " & key
|
|
for line in text.splitLines():
|
|
let s = line.strip()
|
|
if not s.startsWith(prefix): continue
|
|
var rest = s[prefix.len .. ^1].strip()
|
|
if rest.len == 0 or rest[0] != '=': continue
|
|
rest = rest[1 .. ^1].strip()
|
|
let si = rest.find("(source:")
|
|
if si >= 0: rest = rest[0 ..< si].strip()
|
|
return rest
|
|
|
|
proc parseLive(text: string): Live =
|
|
var lastTarget = -1
|
|
var seen: seq[int]
|
|
for raw in text.splitLines():
|
|
let s = stripAnsi(raw).strip()
|
|
if s.startsWith("[config] "):
|
|
inc result.configLines
|
|
let i = s.find("target=#")
|
|
if i >= 0:
|
|
var j = i + "target=#".len
|
|
var neg = false
|
|
if j < s.len and s[j] == '-': neg = true; inc j
|
|
var num = 0
|
|
var any = false
|
|
while j < s.len and s[j] in {'0'..'9'}:
|
|
num = num * 10 + (ord(s[j]) - ord('0')); inc j; any = true
|
|
if any and not neg:
|
|
if lastTarget >= 0 and num != lastTarget: inc result.targetChanges
|
|
lastTarget = num
|
|
if num notin seen: seen.add num
|
|
elif s.startsWith("[rack] "):
|
|
if " mode=melee " in s or s.endsWith(" mode=melee"):
|
|
inc result.rackMeleeLines
|
|
elif s.startsWith("[bb-reset] ") and "reason=target_change" in s:
|
|
inc result.bbResetTargetChange
|
|
elif s.startsWith("[bb] "):
|
|
inc result.bbLines
|
|
elif s.startsWith("[result] battle END:"):
|
|
let i = s.find("rounds won ")
|
|
if i >= 0: result.resultEndWon = s[i + "rounds won ".len .. ^1].strip()
|
|
result.distinctTargets = seen.len
|
|
result.envRackPattern = envLine(text, "TR_RACK_PATTERN")
|
|
result.envRackBitbrain = envLine(text, "TR_RACK_BITBRAIN")
|
|
result.envBitbrainMem = envLine(text, "TR_BITBRAIN_MEM")
|
|
result.envBitbrainGains = envLine(text, "TR_BITBRAIN_GAINS")
|
|
result.envMovement = envLine(text, "TR_MOVEMENT")
|
|
result.rackActiveMelee = envLine(text, "rack active melee")
|
|
result.rackActive1v1 = envLine(text, "rack active 1v1")
|
|
|
|
# ── one run ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
|
|
|
|
proc runOne(repo, outdir, bin, armName: string, env: seq[string],
|
|
run, rounds, timeout: int, commit, binsha: string): bool =
|
|
let armDir = outdir / armName
|
|
createDir(armDir)
|
|
let work = outdir / "work" / armName / ("run" & $run)
|
|
let botDir = work / "ModularBot"
|
|
let outLog = armDir / ("run" & $run & ".bot.stdout.log")
|
|
let errLog = armDir / ("run" & $run & ".bot.stderr.log")
|
|
let runLog = armDir / ("run" & $run & ".runner.log")
|
|
let jsonPath = armDir / ("run" & $run & ".json")
|
|
if fileExists(outLog): removeFile(outLog)
|
|
if fileExists(errLog): removeFile(errLog)
|
|
writeWrapper(botDir, env, bin, outLog, errLog)
|
|
|
|
var advDirs: seq[string]
|
|
for a in AdversaryNames: advDirs.add repo / repoSuffix / a
|
|
|
|
var ok = true
|
|
var raw = ""
|
|
try:
|
|
raw = runBattleRunner(getServerUrl(), @[botDir] & advDirs, rounds, timeout, true)
|
|
except CatchableError as e:
|
|
ok = false
|
|
raw = "EXCEPTION: " & e.msg
|
|
writeFile(runLog, raw)
|
|
|
|
if not ok:
|
|
writeFile(jsonPath, $(%*{"arm": armName, "run": run, "rounds": rounds,
|
|
"commit": commit, "binary_sha256": binsha,
|
|
"ok": false, "error": raw}))
|
|
stderr.writeLine(fmt"[melee] {armName} run {run}: FAILED")
|
|
return false
|
|
|
|
let r = parseServerOutput(raw)
|
|
var perRound: seq[tuple[round, score, rank: int, survived: bool]]
|
|
var botRd: seq[JsonNode]
|
|
for rr in r.rounds:
|
|
for br in rr.results:
|
|
if br.name == "ModularBot":
|
|
perRound.add (rr.round, br.score, br.rank, br.survived)
|
|
|
|
var modJ = %*{"name": "ModularBot", "found": false}
|
|
for b in r.results:
|
|
if b.name == "ModularBot":
|
|
modJ = %*{"name": b.name, "totalScore": b.totalScore, "rank": b.rank,
|
|
"firstPlaces": b.firstPlaces, "survivalCount": b.survivalCount,
|
|
"found": true}
|
|
var field = newJArray()
|
|
for b in r.results:
|
|
if b.name == "ModularBot": continue
|
|
field.add %*{"name": b.name, "totalScore": b.totalScore, "rank": b.rank,
|
|
"firstPlaces": b.firstPlaces, "survivalCount": b.survivalCount}
|
|
|
|
for pr in perRound:
|
|
botRd.add %*{"round": pr.round, "score": pr.score, "rank": pr.rank,
|
|
"survived": pr.survived}
|
|
|
|
var live = Live()
|
|
if fileExists(outLog):
|
|
live = parseLive(readFile(outLog))
|
|
|
|
let row = %*{
|
|
"arm": armName, "run": run, "rounds": rounds,
|
|
"commit": commit, "binary_sha256": binsha,
|
|
"ok": true,
|
|
"modularbot": modJ,
|
|
"field": field,
|
|
"perRound": botRd,
|
|
"live": %*{
|
|
"env_TR_RACK_PATTERN": live.envRackPattern,
|
|
"env_TR_RACK_BITBRAIN": live.envRackBitbrain,
|
|
"env_TR_BITBRAIN_MEM": live.envBitbrainMem,
|
|
"env_TR_BITBRAIN_GAINS": live.envBitbrainGains,
|
|
"env_TR_MOVEMENT": live.envMovement,
|
|
"rack_active_melee": live.rackActiveMelee,
|
|
"rack_active_1v1": live.rackActive1v1,
|
|
"rack_melee_lines": live.rackMeleeLines,
|
|
"config_lines": live.configLines,
|
|
"distinct_targets": live.distinctTargets,
|
|
"target_changes": live.targetChanges,
|
|
"bb_reset_target_change": live.bbResetTargetChange,
|
|
"bb_lines": live.bbLines,
|
|
"result_end_won": live.resultEndWon
|
|
}
|
|
}
|
|
writeFile(jsonPath, $(row))
|
|
let mb = r.results.filterIt(it.name == "ModularBot")
|
|
let wins = if mb.len > 0: mb[0].firstPlaces else: 0
|
|
let rk = if mb.len > 0: mb[0].rank else: 0
|
|
let sc = if mb.len > 0: mb[0].totalScore else: 0
|
|
echo fmt"[melee] {armName} run {run}: wins={wins}/{rounds} rank={rk} score={sc} " &
|
|
fmt"targets={live.distinctTargets} changes={live.targetChanges} " &
|
|
fmt"rackMelee={live.rackActiveMelee} bbreset={live.bbResetTargetChange}"
|
|
result = true
|
|
|
|
# ── main ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
|
|
|
|
proc main() =
|
|
let repo = repoRoot()
|
|
let args = params()
|
|
if hasFlag(args, "--list-arms") or hasFlag(args, "--help") or args.len == 0:
|
|
echo "arms:"
|
|
for a in Arms:
|
|
echo a.name & "\t" & a.env.join(" ") & "\t" & a.note
|
|
return
|
|
let outdir = findParam(args, "--outdir", "/tmp/melee_bitbrain_ab")
|
|
createDir(outdir)
|
|
let commit = headCommit(repo)
|
|
let bin = buildFrozen(repo, outdir)
|
|
let binsha = binarySha(bin)
|
|
echo "[melee] commit=", commit, " binary_sha256=", binsha
|
|
if hasFlag(args, "--build-only"): return
|
|
|
|
let armName = findParam(args, "--arm")
|
|
if armName.len == 0:
|
|
stderr.writeLine("--arm is required (or --list-arms / --build-only)")
|
|
quit(1)
|
|
var arm: Arm
|
|
var found = false
|
|
for a in Arms:
|
|
if a.name == armName: arm = a; found = true
|
|
if not found:
|
|
stderr.writeLine("unknown arm: " & armName)
|
|
quit(1)
|
|
|
|
let runStart = parseInt(findParam(args, "--run-start", "1"))
|
|
let runCount = parseInt(findParam(args, "--run-count", "15"))
|
|
let rounds = parseInt(findParam(args, "--rounds", "7"))
|
|
let timeout = parseInt(findParam(args, "--timeout", "900000"))
|
|
let retries = parseInt(findParam(args, "--retries", "2"))
|
|
|
|
# `--runs 1,3,5` overrides the contiguous range (used to fill failed runs).
|
|
var runList: seq[int]
|
|
let runsSpec = findParam(args, "--runs", "")
|
|
if runsSpec.len > 0:
|
|
for t in runsSpec.split(','):
|
|
let s = t.strip()
|
|
if s.len > 0: runList.add parseInt(s)
|
|
else:
|
|
for run in runStart ..< runStart + runCount: runList.add run
|
|
|
|
ensureServer()
|
|
echo "[melee] server=", getServerUrl(), " arm=", armName,
|
|
" runs=", runList.len, " rounds=", rounds, " retries=", retries
|
|
|
|
var ok = 0
|
|
for run in runList:
|
|
var done = false
|
|
for attempt in 1 .. retries + 1:
|
|
if runOne(repo, outdir, bin, armName, arm.env, run, rounds, timeout, commit, binsha):
|
|
done = true
|
|
break
|
|
if attempt <= retries:
|
|
stderr.writeLine(fmt"[melee] {armName} run {run}: retry {attempt}/{retries} in 8s")
|
|
sleep(8000)
|
|
if done: inc ok
|
|
echo fmt"[melee] {armName}: {ok}/{runList.len} runs ok"
|
|
|
|
when isMainModule:
|
|
main()
|